--- ---

AJ’S Sushi & Cajun Seafood

Rating:

 4.5

Cost:

$20 – $30

About AJ’s Sushi & Cajun Seafood in Suffern, NY

AJ’s Sushi & Cajun Seafood in Suffern, NY, stands out as a casual dining spot offering an all-you-can-eat menu that combines fresh sushi with flavorful cooked dishes, making it a go-to for seafood enthusiasts. The restaurant features a welcoming atmosphere with accessible options like wheelchair-friendly seating and parking, ensuring everyone can enjoy the experience comfortably. Diners appreciate the variety of high-quality sushi rolls and Cajun-inspired seafood, all served at moderate prices that provide great value for families and groups. With its focus on fresh ingredients and a solid reputation among sushi places near me, this spot delivers a satisfying meal that balances taste and affordability.

Summarized by AI using the Grok-3-Mini model.

Insights from Recent Feedback

Visitors to AJ’s Sushi & Cajun Seafood often rave about the fresh sushi and all-you-can-eat deals that make it a fun, value-packed choice for seafood lovers in the area. While some folks note that the service can vary, the overall highlights include tasty specialty rolls and generous portions that keep people coming back for more. It's clear that the quality of the fish and creative dishes hit the mark for those seeking top-rated sushi experiences, though a few mention minor inconsistencies in preparation to keep things real. All in all, this spot maintains a positive vibe for casual diners looking for reliable options, with the consensus leaning toward it being a solid pick for anyone exploring sushi restaurants nearby.

Summarized by AI using the Grok-3-Mini model.

Address & Phone

8 N Airmont Rd
Suffern, NY 10901
(845) 547-2326

Wheelchair Accessiblility

Parking:Restroom:Seating:

Parking Options

Free parking lot:Free street parking:Valet parking:

Payment Options

Accepts credit cards:Accepts debit cards:Accepts nfc:

Reviews

  • Yesee

     4

    The sushi was delicious and came out quickly. Although the servers didn’t smile or seem very friendly, the food was so good that I’ve already visited twice. The salmon sashimi, in particular, was incredibly fresh and absolutely top-notch.

  • James Thompson

     3

    Who doesn't like a good 'all-you-can-eat'? Sometimes, despite better judgment, one just has to let their inner 'fat-kid' out and go nuts. But let's be perfectly clear on something - it is very rare should one come across an a.y.c.e. where the food is exceptional. Most a.y.c.e.'s are about pumping out lots of cheaply prepared, carb-rich, salty food that separates a fool from his dollar after just two plates. Now, if you're a seasoned buffet professional, you know all the secrets to swindling the swindlers. Start with the proteins, specifically the high-end stuff - skip all the things that are going to trip you up; rice, noodles, pastas, and breads. I like to start with the snow crab legs, lobster tails, boiled shrimp (not fried), and obviously, Prime Rib. But you won't find any of those items on the menu here. This establishment gives you two options. Just two. Sushi or Cajun. Now, I know that sounds bizarre, and it is. You can't even combine from one menu to the next. You have to make the decision whether or not you want Sushi or Cajun. Now this is a conundrum for me, because Sushi and Cajun cuisines are my favorite - so you can imagine my disappointment when I asked to do both and the waitress said I had to pick just one menu. Major Point Reduction. I went with Sushi. And the wife and I went all out. Okay, truthfully, we went overboard. The result, well... I had mixed reviews. You see, they did some things right, but mostly wrong. And they prepared a few things well, but mainly, it was kind of mediocre. We started with a Miso soup. It was tasty, but it was practically all broth and little to no tofu, scallions, and nori. Next, grilled squid, or ikayaki, in a teriyaki glaze. It was okay. But the shumai and the gyoza, now those were good (even though I think they came from a bag). Then our sushi arrived, and I realized that perhaps we had been a little overzealous, as the pictures would suggest. But I wasn't about to pay the additional fee for food wasted charge, so I soldiered on and finished my meal with zest and fervor... and immediately regretted the overexuberance of my folly. It was my first and only meal of the day. I couldn't eat another bite afterward. Now, as for the sushi. The quality of the ingredients was very good, but the preparation was lacking. The fish to rice ratio favored the rice, and the rice was underseasoned. For $28.99 per person, we pigged out - and that's okay. I was in a sushi coma by the meals end. But was it worth pig-out? My answer: sort of. Some of the rolls were very tasty, and others were bland. The fact that specialty rolls and common rolls are both included in the same price means that a diner should stick to the specialty rolls - you get a lot more value for what you are given. But if nigiri is your thing, then this place is a bit of a letdown. I was disappointed that the nigiri pieces I ordered were as bland as they were. If you're the kind of person who mixes Wasabi into your soy sauce and drowns your maki pieces in the mixture after slathering each piece with a slice of pickled ginger, or a person who values quanity over quality, then this place is perfect for you. If you are, however, a purist, then stick to your high-end omakase. Would I go back? Yes, I believe I would; but to try the Cajun side of the menu and compare my findings, or to scratch a sushi gorgefest if ever the craving to be a disgusting piglet arises again.

  • Gab Gatdula

     5

    I’ve been a regular customer at AJ’s. I’ve eaten here at least 15x for the past 5 years. They have the best quality of fish for sushi for an AYCE. Every time I wanna try an AYCE sushi closer to me, I always just end up driving to AJ’s as I am sure the quality is great!

  • Arianna Iris

     2

    The server didn’t seem like she wanted to be there. We Got a bento box for my man. The miso was soapy tasting and the meat was dry. I got a $60 seafood boil. They were accommodating to switch the clams and mussels for shrimp however the shrimp and crab were inedible. The crab was either heavily salted or old. The shrimp were so overcooked I couldn’t get any of the skins off. They were also unclean, it was so frustrating. I ordered a Kani hand roll and took everything to go so I didn’t feel embarrassed. Disappointing to say the least. Weird v-day vibez.

  • Briana Van Dorpe

     3

    I came here with my mom a while ago, when it was under different management. I was disappointed in the food when we went earlier today because it seems like a total downgrade. I got a spicy tuna roll and they used canned tuna. The salad didn’t even come with a ginger dressing, it tasted like watered down mayo. The salmon also didn’t look real. Also, they have a “limiting food waste” policy & will charge you 30% of your total bill for any food left over. When I asked if we could pay to take home, we were told it wasn’t possible. Even if you paid. Seems counter productive. Overall, we spent $100 for 2 people & mediocre sushi. The soups were good, and I wonder if the KBBQ is a better? Our waiter was the best thing there; he was really kind, friendly, and helpful. I didn’t catch his name, but he deserves 10/10

--- ---